I'll never buy Framework hardware again

(poolp.org)

154 points | by unchar1 38 minutes ago

23 comments

  • rpdillon 8 minutes ago
    I've stayed pretty quiet about this, but as an early and enthusiastic Framework supporter, I cannot recommend them to anyone.

    I bought the Framework 13 before launch, and received a machine from the first batch. I later bought their main board upgrade kit and their screen upgrade kit and I did a full upgrade on the machine and rebuilt it. The reason I could justify that was that I would take the old main board and slip it into their Cooler Master case and use it as a spare machine.

    But there was a bug in the Intel chip they used in that main board that prevented it from booting properly inside of the Cooler Master case, and going back and forth with support, what they wanted me to do was disassemble my other computers to troubleshoot the one that should have just worked. They didn't offer a replacement. They didn't allow me to send it in to have them fix it. When I explained that I didn't want to disassemble my working machines to fix my broken machine, they stopped replying to me.

    This, coupled with the horrendous battery issues in the first version of the Framework 13, led me to conclude another purchase from them would be a big mistake.

    Still happy with all six of my System76 purchases.

    • rationalist 6 minutes ago
      > bug in the Intel chip

      It sounds like the problem was Intel's and not theirs, yrt they still went out of their way to help you.

      • rpdillon 5 minutes ago
        They didn't go out of their way to help me at all, in fact they did nothing. Engineering teams that choose components are responsible for those choices. Framework neglected to take any responsibility whatsoever.
        • cromka 3 minutes ago
          Idk, it sounds to me that in this particular case you would have same exact experience with every other OEM out there?
          • rpdillon 0 minutes ago
            If the other OEM had chosen that exact same chipset, and if that other OEM neglected to do anything to fix it, then yes, my experience would be the same.

            But, during this period I've been buying computers steadily from System76, and they have been incredibly supportive when I came to them with an issue (to be fair, I've only ever had to work with System76 support once, but it was a very positive experience).

            So no, I don't think it's fair to assume that I would have had the same experience with any OEM. Different OEMs could choose different chipsets, and they could choose to be more supportive.

          • spider-mario 1 minute ago
            What other OEM would have you disassemble other machines you own and refuse to do anything if you don’t?
        • rationalist 1 minute ago
          It worked... in the Framework which is what their engineering team designed it for.

          Why would they take responsibilty for thirdparty hardware.

      • echoangle 0 minutes ago
        Why would I as a customer care about their supplier? If you buy a car and the motor the car brand bought is faulty, do you ask the car brand or the motor supplier to fix it?
      • LegitShady 4 minutes ago
        they didn't buy a chip from intel, they bought a computer from framework, and the support to make sure it works is frameworks, not intel's. framework can deal with intel.

        imagine you buy a car and the electronics stop working and the manufacturer says "hey your problem is with bosch, go bug them" - you didn't buy anything from bosch, you bought a car and dealing with defective bosch parts is the manufacturer/dealer's problem, not yours.

        • rationalist 2 minutes ago
          It worked... in the Framework which is what their engineers designed it for.

          So your analogy would be: I took the engine out of the car and put it in my bosch, and now it worn't work.

  • paxy 9 minutes ago
    Why waste so much time with support? It should have been clear after week 1 that they aren't interested in helping you.

    Consumer protection laws exist for a reason. Collect all the documentation and file a chargeback. This is the only way the problem will actually get escalated.

    • dchest 0 minutes ago
      Consumer protection laws are usually weaker when buying as a business.
  • Aurornis 14 minutes ago
    I wish they had posted the short story instead of having AI expand it into this formulaic multi-section prose (Pangram agrees), but the frustrations in this story sound too familiar. Framework is a company whose mission I support and I want to succeed, but I know too many people who have had negative experiences like this.

    Making entire computers is hard, and making then upgradeable is even harder. Getting warranty work and customer support right is table stakes for selling a computer, though.

    • drum55 11 minutes ago
      It's annoying that what should have been a human telling a story has got turned into tortured llm prose, it's hard to have any sympathy for the author when it's viewed through the claude-lens.
      • testtestmetest 3 minutes ago
        Reading llm text makes me dizzy, literally in some cases. I dont want to even flip through them.
  • zackify 0 minutes ago
    If anyone is interested, I had a recent framework 13 pro and a mainboard issue.

    They did offer replacement after about 4 emails.

    I am a bit surprised a fault this bad couldn’t be caught during QA. But they’re also a small company and I’m just waiting now for my replacement to come. May be more on intel’s side too than them.

    More details on my issue here https://community.frame.work/t/laptop-13-pro-core-ultra-x7-3...

  • drum55 13 minutes ago
    A business should have trashed it or returned it and moved on, the "support" is specifically designed to waste time and frustrate people into giving up on the hardware as you found. I don't understand why the developer would have been "without a laptop" given it could have been replaced in under an hour, you don't even have to go to a store you can get someone on Uber Eats to pick up a functional laptop, unless this is just stuff a LLM added for flavor. If this was anything more than a brief annoyance I don't understand how you're running a company.
    • rationalist 9 minutes ago
      Exactly: Something breaks within the return window - return it, don't gamble with support.
  • thewillowcat 15 minutes ago
    I have a Framework 13. I really like it, and I would buy Framework hardware again. But I also wouldn't buy one for an engineer at my company to use as a daily driver in a world where the MacBook Pro exists. I think this misreads where Framework is in its stage of development.
    • tetsuo420 12 minutes ago
      Could you elaborate on that, if you don't mind? I was thinking about either getting the 13 Pro or a second-hand M2 with Asahi and this would help me decide.
      • kami23 5 minutes ago
        Not OP but a developer not working is going to much more expensive in loss of productivity than whatever you save in having modular hardware or cool points.

        Repairability is fine, but when working at the scale that you even have a handful or employees and no dedicated IT or even slightly larger than that the hardware shouldn't be a work stoppage, so having hot spares for folks to be swapped immediately and having higher quality machines pays off very quickly.

        Mac laptops are some of the highest quality longest last laptops I've worked with, I ran my 2015 mbp into the ground, it still works and was fine with Linux on it after all these years, but it made it a no brainer for me to get a Neo this year, if I get a decade out of this guy as well I will be happy.

      • thewillowcat 1 minute ago
        The MBP is physically robust and I don't have to apply any effort to keep it running perfectly. It just works.

        It takes time and effort to keep Linux running smoothly on my Framework. I don't feel as confident about throwing the Framework in a backpack and traveling with it. I don't expect it to take as much physical abuse over time.

    • LtWorf 9 minutes ago
      What if the engineer wants to use the keyboard?
      • Analemma_ 6 minutes ago
        You’re about five years too late with this joke.
  • maeln 7 minutes ago
    I love my Framework 13 to death to the point that I cannot see myself buying any other laptop, but I gotta say, Framework really have to up their QA and customer service game. We also decided to use Framework laptop at work, and we had several with issues. Mine has a broken webcam module and came with a whiny high pitch CPU fan. I did not care for the webcam (hey, can't hack something that doesn't work), but the CPU fan was incredibly annoying. I had to do several rounds of email with Framework support before they send me the replacement part. And we are based in E.U so we have the automatic 2-year guarantee. Idk if it would have been possible outside of the E.U.

    I really love the module system, the screen ratio, the linux support, the 180° hinge. But I think it is fair that the frequent QA problem is a dealbreaker for a lot of people (especially at the price point that they ask). For me, as long as they don't fix this, it will mean that Framework stays a niche manufacturer for enthusiast.

  • elteto 7 minutes ago
    That’s why I don’t bother with going through support channels if I’m within the refund period. Either send me a new one after the first email or give me a refund. Or if I really want _that_ thing I will skip support and buy an identical new unit while I initiate the return, to get the replacement ASAP. If the manufacturer gets cute or refuses a refund the it goes straight to a chargeback on my credit card, no back and forth.
  • scotth 2 minutes ago
    Just want to put it out there that I don't feel this way, and I will be buying Framework again. I like it quite a bit.
  • tombert 11 minutes ago
    In 2024 I was looking for a laptop to replace my T2 Macbook, and being a pretty geeky dude I was leaning towards Framework. I ultimately ended up getting my Thinkpad P16s just because it was a fair bit cheaper for better hardware, and I absolutely love it.

    Looking at this I'm kind of glad that that's the direction I went.

  • perks_12 7 minutes ago
    I have a Framwork 13 (with the 11th gen Intel). I don't hate it, but I wouldn't recommend it either.

    Battery life is abysmal. That is even after the battery upgrade kit was installed.

    Recently I swapped the bezel, which was easy, and hey, you can do it. But I never had the wish to replace it with literally any other laptop I ever owned. But on the framework, the plastic bezels somehow disintegrated, and I basically had loose strings of it hanging around.

    • cromka 1 minute ago
      But that's any hardware with old Intel CPU. I don't see how Framework is at fault here.
  • cheschire 11 minutes ago
    Scaling is tough. Being a small scrappy company is a lot easier when your customer count matches your employee headcount. Hitting those next couple performance levels though when you scale from hundreds to thousands, then tens of thousands, then hundreds of thousands… those are effectively completely different company structures.
    • coldpie 2 minutes ago
      I've never run a business, but I'm surprised how consistent businesses are in providing absolutely miserable customer support. The customer support team is the face of your business to the people who are directly giving you money. If your customers are walking away from their customer support experience unhappy, then they are going to hate your business. Employees in customer support should be top-notch and have the power to make things right by the customer at any cost. If your customer support is giving out big piles of money in replacement parts, that's not the support team's fault, that's a fault somewhere else in your company that needs to be fixed.
  • jckahn 12 minutes ago
    I'm perfectly happy with my AMD Framework 13 and would absolutely buy one again. I won't need to for a while though, as I've been able to upgrade mine as necessary over that last two years or so.
  • jon128 1 minute ago
    Framework's repair center ran complete diagnostics, tested two keyboards, and found that those two keyboards were working perfectly.

    All these guys had to do was order a new keyboard. If they demanded a refund for the not-working keyboard they'd get one. I know, from experience having handled dozens of Framework laptops, Framework absolutely will do this.

    You'd think someone offering consulting services would be a bit sharper..

    The criticisms of the ticket ownership posture are helpful (depending on how accurate they actually are), I have forwarded this along to someone high up in Framework's support branch of its org chart I have a good connection with.

  • Brass 15 minutes ago
    Wow.

    Stinks because I need to replace an aging MacBook and was leaning Framework.

    Is Omarchy on a MacBook the way to go for mobile Linux these days or?

    • jsbisviewtiful 6 minutes ago
      As someone who recently tried installing Linux as the primary OS on an old Macbook... wouldn't recommend it. With all the proprietary parts in Apple products, it's a wing and a prayer situation in hoping the distro has all the drivers figured out. On my 2017 MBP, the drivers for opening/closing the lid and activating/deactivating sleep mode, bluetooth and wifi all had not been fully figured out. Made for a lousy experience and this was the Ubuntu distro for that laptop specifically.

      It's also worth saying this, but anytime someone posts a review, or in this case a whole AI written blog, about something, there's a good chance that person is an outlier unless there is significantly more examples. Folks are a lot more prone to complain online than they are to compliment. That this user was so lazy they AI-wrote this blog post also doesn't help their credibility.

    • mzajc 2 minutes ago
      Maybe I'm just exceptionally lucky, but I've used Debian on several "mainstream" laptop brands (HP, Dell, Lenovo, etc.), including newest models, and the worst issue I've run into is that firmware updates require more fiddling than on Windows, so it's ten minutes of work instead of one. Besides that, everything has always worked as expected.
    • jjice 14 minutes ago
      FWIW I've been using a Framework AMD 13 for a bit over three years now without any issues.
      • tetsuo420 11 minutes ago
        anything you would highlight about it (good or bad)? how is the battery life?
    • cwnyth 12 minutes ago
      I was looking to replace my Lenovo with a Framework. Guess that's out now. What a shame, as I prefer to support Linux-friendly vendors.
      • wvenable 0 minutes ago
        Basing your purchasing decisions on a single bad experience anecdote just means that there won't be a single vendor that will satisfy you.
      • coldpie 8 minutes ago
        I've been using a Framework for a few years. I'm still happy with it and would get one again if I needed one. However I've never had to contact support, so I can't say anything positive or negative about that experience.
      • hollowonepl 8 minutes ago
        Choose System76 computers instead of Framework. Framework comes with nice promise but lack of commitment to make it true and globally available. Very US centric company that in the first pre-sales contact smelled fishy and it seems I luckily dropped of considering them at right stage!
      • MaKey 7 minutes ago
        Lenovo is Linux-friendly though. A lot of their laptops are Ubuntu certified.
    • nticompass 9 minutes ago
      Why would you consider Omarchy over all the other, much better, less problematic Linux distros?
  • reshux 6 minutes ago
    I got a Framework 13 in 2021. I was so excited to use it. I had to repair it multiple times, first when it was 2 years old, second time when it was 4 years old. I know the point of having a Framework is repairability and upgrades, but I never had to repair a laptop before, especially during the first 5 years.

    I first had to use it as a professional dev device in late 2025, before that it was just a light personal laptop for me. It suuuuucked as a dev device for me. I got a Macbook Pro again.

    Their customer support experience is slow and really infuriating, even for design faults they admitted and for things they offer free replacements.

  • SV_BubbleTime 7 minutes ago
    Let’s see…

    On a 16 I thought for an employee, he had two full ssd corruptions. FW sent new SSDs, but they didn’t really care to diagnose the issue. Turned out to be a bad motherboard only after I refused to accept a third ssd.

    On my 13, the battery dies in shutdown, constantly. Linux OS, if I don’t shutdown completely it’s dead in a day. If I shutdown completely it’s dead in three days. I have a surface pro 3 and 5 with OLD batteries that last months in shutdown.

    Other units have had bad trackpads, keyboards, webcam, randomness like the keyboard light going in and out, and I had a screen die just outside of warranty.

    YES, all these issues would be fixable with just one tool. The economics of replacement parts is wildly different when I look back to how much I’ve had to spend on the four frameworks we have vs the thousand non-frameworks we’ve gone through.

    I want to like them.

  • trentor 9 minutes ago
    Same. Horrible experience all over.
  • orblivion 4 minutes ago
    Okay so which one is the good company then? Seems like every option sucks for one reason or another.
  • artemonster 7 minutes ago
    the dream of open repairable hardware is dead
    • vvpan 4 minutes ago
      Why do you say that?
  • ragall 6 minutes ago
    Too bad it's completely LLM-written.
  • dtj1123 8 minutes ago
    Eh. I'm still buying one.
  • vvpan 4 minutes ago
    It is hard to be a small manufacturer, especially with the lofty goals of Framework, let's keep that in mind before throwing too much dirt.