European RISC-V Industrial Computing Initiative

(erici.eu)

99 points | by ymz5 1 day ago

15 comments

  • clarionbell 17 minutes ago
    And the chips will be manufactured in China. Truly a genius move.
  • hn_submit 1 hour ago
    Is this something more than a flag-waiving exercise? Who's actually manufacturing and selling these "European" CPUs?

    I just purchased a boatload of Chinese RISC-V development boards for about $2.30 a piece. Can't wait to start playing with them.

    "RISC(-V) architecture is going to change everything."

    [1]: https://www.aliexpress.com/item/1005011967676963.html

    • asdfsa32 55 minutes ago
      Who actually builds these manufacturing facilities? Is America just a financial services empire now? Two can play this game.
    • sigmoid10 32 minutes ago
      Compared to x86, which is wholly owned by an American duopoly and needs licensing to produce legally, boosting RISC-V is a major step towards chip independence for Europe. With the current state of the US it almost seems a necessity. The only downside here is that it didn't happen sooner.
      • hn_submit 16 minutes ago
        Even if Intel licensed x86 no one in Europe would want to make them. Unless they're guaranteed a monopoly there will be no takers. European companies and conglomerates are extremely lazy and risk averse.

        All they want is to suck on the government's tit.

      • glimshe 26 minutes ago
        What about ARM? Isn't it also European?
        • lioeters 10 minutes ago
          While ARM Holdings is based in Cambridge, England, it is majority owned by SoftBank Group which is a Japanese investment conglomerate.

          What's important in the context of a European "sovereign computing" initiative is the licensing of the instruction set architecture. Like x86, ARM is still proprietary, while RISC-V is a free and open standard.

          • pepperoni_pizza 4 minutes ago
            SoftBank is technically hedquartered in Japan but it is mostly owned by Saudis.
        • hn_submit 4 minutes ago
          It is if you define the UK being in Europe (the continent). It isn't part of the EU as of today, although there's a good chance it will be again in the future.

          Even though it's Japanese-owned most of their R&D still takes place in England.

  • PowerElectronix 7 minutes ago
    Very sad that the silicon itself is not made in EU.
  • cbolton 26 minutes ago
    This is just a webpage some individual put up, right? I mean as far as I can see there's no institute, no company, no government behind this. Just one RISC-V enthusiast on the contact page.
    • revengerwizard 21 minutes ago
      It also seems AI generated?

      Great idea, but if the important EU players aren't there, what's the point?

  • Havoc 38 minutes ago
    Neat. This seems like exactly the sort of thing Europe should be pushing
  • ShadowOfThePit 2 hours ago
    > A machine expected to run for 15 years should not depend on one company's roadmap, or one government's decisions."

    > A machine that runs for 15 years needs software that can be maintained for 15 years.

    I don't quite understand. Has this been a problem for industrial machines? Can't they already run for 30 years and more?

    What exactly is this initiative looking to fix and improve? Besides of the basic idea of FOSS being good, and whatever.

    • InvisibleUp 1 hour ago
      They can run, but if one of the computer-related parts breaks down your only choice is scrounging eBay for replacement parts because (as an example) the software is proprietary and it runs on a weird MCA card with really precise timing and strong anti-piracy measures.
    • rurifi33 2 hours ago
      In the 90s and early 2000s server uptime might be counted in multiple years and extremes in the decades

      The industry can barely keep an npm update from breaking the world now.. and that’s build tools and environments and so it’s independent of “we use stable languages”

      Now add the possibility of political sanctions on ISA licensing and you have -

      Hardware that’s fails quicker and may not be available to buy, software that barely builds months later, and a world where the US president can sanction entities at will if they don’t comply…

      Yeah, open source isn’t all that’s required

      • renszarv 1 hour ago
        I do remember a Freebsd 2.2 server, that after it's setup in 98, reached 800 days of uptime without any kernel upgrade, but the main reason for that, we were too afraid to do an upgrade, let alone a reboot, because if the server hadn't started, getting to it physically with a new boot CD, would have been a big issue. And that was the single server that the company had at that time, for a long time :)
  • blitzar 51 minutes ago
    RISC architecture's going to change everything.
    • usrnm 4 minutes ago
      RISC architecture is about as old as x86
    • wvbdmp 45 minutes ago
      Yeah, RISC is good.
  • perarneng 2 hours ago
    CPEU is coming! I love RISC-V and have been following its progress for so long. I hope it gets more and more adoption in the world for desktops and servers. Its already massive in MCU's but we need it everywhere. Open ISA is the best ISA
    • vaylian 2 hours ago
      What is CPEU? I don't see that acronym on the page.
      • rurifi33 2 hours ago
        Probably a nice merge of CPU and EU
        • perarneng 40 minutes ago
          Just something I made up when promoting that EU should make CPU's . So its exactly what you say a merge of CPU and EU :-)
      • jabl 2 hours ago
        Google says it's "CPEU most commonly stands for Continuing Professional Education Unit, a credit system used by dietitians and nutrition professionals.". Yeah, not sure how that is related to RISC-V. Perhaps we should eat RISC-V powered nanobots to, uh, future sci-fi something?
  • hollowonepl 2 hours ago
    I like RISC-V as a concept but still only Chinese are focused on manufacturing those today.

    So.. it's a bit funny to read there is an European Initiative... to promote Chinese computer appliances.

    In times when fridges with Chinese electronics that are phoning home become more hack-able today than ever..

    • pjmlp 1 hour ago
      That goes to show how low the things have gone with the US administration.

      In fact several countries do support Huawei store in addition to Apple and Google ones, including having the usual bank apps available there.

      https://consumer.huawei.com/pt/offer

      https://consumer.huawei.com/pt/campanhas/appgallery

    • csmantle 1 hour ago
      It's interesting to see that both "Firefly AIBOX-K3" and "Milk-V Jupiter2" use cores from SpacemiT, a Chinese company. It's even listed as the "Reference stack" that is "Defined together, verified together"!

      > Hardware

      > RVA23 SoC with IOMMU

      > SpacemiT K3

      > 8× X100 cores, hypervisor extension, IOMMU

    • GoblinSlayer 1 hour ago
      There's glorious open hardware rpi pico 2.
  • dcreater 4 hours ago
    Vibe coded site and copy
    • soltanov 4 hours ago
      i am tired of seeing same patterns and designs on Internet. It is kind of frustration
      • minetest2048 2 hours ago
        And also real life.. there's no reason why a laundromat, barbershop and Japanese restaurant have posters that looks similar
        • soltanov 2 hours ago
          Agree, all of them in same industry mostly have similar posters. My eyes keep ignoring them and focus on service quality of barbershop and restaurants.
      • anonzzzies 3 hours ago
        By now I just want everything just to be black on white or white on black text and nothing else. Or better, just an md file.
      • dcreater 4 hours ago
        Yet it will be worse when we aren't able to detect it as easily
        • exit 3 hours ago
          what exactly will be worse once no qualitative difference is detectible?
          • jsumn 2 hours ago
            No difference in presentation doesn't make presented slop content less sloppy.
    • isolli 2 hours ago
      Indeed:

      "RVA23 silicon has arrived. The industrial computer built on it has not."

      "Until recently it lacked what industrial systems need. That has changed."

      So tiresome...

      • ShadowOfThePit 2 hours ago
        "The silicon is here. The industrial computer isn't yet."

        "An industrial computer has to do more: survive the control cabinet, talk to the field, and stay available for a decade or longer."

        Do people think this sounds good?

        And what if it does, but you and I are just tired from seeing it everywhere?

    • nine_k 3 hours ago
      Is it content-free? I don't think so. Is it hard to read? I don't think so either. Is it incorrect? I hope it's not %))

      Does it sound like a typical LLM-generated text? In many areas, it does. But why would I care? This is not expected to be a piece of literary art. Equally, the pictures illustrating it are not artistic masterpieces, and aren't expected to be. And even the letters in the text are not carefully handwritten by a human but machine-generated.

      Get used to it, and get past it. It's not worth the attention.

  • orbifold 58 minutes ago
    Pure model slop. When I read this I get a headache and feel repulsed.
    • asdfsa32 53 minutes ago
      Yes, Dead internet stinks and is approaching faster than AI market collapse.
    • IshKebab 52 minutes ago
      Likewise. I'm a RISC-V fan but a slop page like this is not a good look.
  • ur-whale 1 hour ago
    > European RISC-V Industrial Computing Initiative > Based in Europe, open worldwide

    So European, right?

    I'm immediately thinking: there's got to be some sort of sovereign aspect to the initiative ... right?

    I mean, if there's one place you want a silicon stack that wasn't manufactured in China, it's most definitely in the guts of your industrial infrastructure (assuming you still have one, yes, point taken).

    But, if you look at the "The silicon is here." section and dig a little:

    > "Shenzhen MilkV Technology Co., Ltd" [1]

    [1]: https://milkv.io/about

    Wake me up when someone can actually build a computer from scratch with EU-made parts.

    • lioeters 1 hour ago
      > build a computer from scratch

      What would it take to make this possible, if not completely then at least move in the right direction?

      Aside from re-thinking computer manufacturing from the ground up.. RISC-V, or something like it, seems like the right idea as part of the solution.

    • numpad0 31 minutes ago
      A lot of ST made ARM chips should be more or less EU made, or at least Western made
    • vanviegen 25 minutes ago
      > Wake me up when someone can actually build a computer from scratch with EU-made parts.

      That may be a high bar. Would all countries in the world collaborating, except for China, Taiwan and South Korea, even be able to do this?

  • weng 2 hours ago
    [flagged]
  • 0l 2 hours ago
    Yet another "initiative". I remember the European Processor Initiative that went precisely nowhere.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/European_Processor_Initiative

    • goobatrooba 2 hours ago
      Not an expert, but reading the article you linked it seems it was quite stressful?

      > EPI demonstrated several results just after the Phase 2 end in 2026.[11] SiPearl demonstrated the Rhea1 chip running a complete HPC software stack. The system booted on a test board, with a standard Linux distribution running with high-speed HBM memories and their associated hardware performance monitoring counters. It successfully executed the HPL and STREAM benchmarks, demonstrating the readiness of the complete Rhea1 hardware and software ecosystem for HPC workloads to power Exascale systems. Rhea1 features 80 arm® Neoverse V1 cores, more than 61 billion transistors (7.8 billion equivalent gates), built-in High Bandwidth Memory, with 4 stacks of HBM, 4 DDR5 interfaces supporting 2 DIMMs Per Channel, and 104 lanes of PCIe Gen5 interface: up to 6 x 16 lanes + 2 x 4 lanes. Rhea1 was selected for implementation in Jupiter, Europe’s first exascale supercomputer. The next version, Rhea2, was selected for implementation in Alice Recoque, the second European exascale supercomputer.

      And then more paragraphs how work was taken forward..

  • snvzz 2 hours ago
    RISC-V is inevitable.
    • jimbob45 32 minutes ago
      Is it though? AI can rapidly push through an objectively better standard if a group becomes motivated to make one. There’s no need to marry ourselves permanently to a mediocre design like we did with C interop.