Stamp It! All Programs Must Report Their Version

(michael.stapelberg.ch)

17 points | by secure 12 hours ago

3 comments

  • bombcar 17 minutes ago
    Stamps are nice, but git and friends miss something that the VCS of yore would give you - a monotonously increasing number you could stick somewhere in your version - and be able to tell at a glance which was newer.

    2.4.16-12 vs 2.4.16-35 - obviously -35 is later.

    But 2.4.16-bcbd1c6 vs 2.4.16-d645104 - which is later? Compile dates won't necessarily help because "earlier" code could have been compiled later.

    It's forcing the versioning to do something it shouldn't, arguably, but is nice to have something that the user can decipher (even if you still should have the commit).

  • sgbeal 10 hours ago
    > --moreversion

    Suggestion: more conventional and intuitive would be: --version --verbose

  • ploution 10 hours ago
    The version seems to be the number one information in order to avoid making things worse! Not all solutions apply to all versions of a running product.